By Charlie Casey Charlie Casey, CEO at LoyaltyLion
Recently there’s been much for ecommerce retailers to feel unsure about. From pandemics and shipping delays to privacy updates and rising inflation, the goalposts are always moving.
Every new hurdle puts pressure on a retailer’s margins and its ability to grow its business. Brands are left wondering how to react without turning off both new and already loyal customers by compromising on the customer experience.
Some see the only option outside of passing costs onto consumers is to lean on promotions and discounts, but our recent report, The Discounting Playbook, shows a sales-dominated strategy is outdated. Relying on discounts isn’t sustainable if you need to run them all year round. Plus those discounts no longer meet the priorities of your customers and won’t help you build lifetime value and brand loyalty.
Back in simpler times, key discount events dominated retail calendars. Black Friday, seasonal promotions (like Valentine’s Day), and end-of-season sales guaranteed quick sales spikes. Today, these very specific sales periods are becoming less relevant, for a few key reasons.
Consumer confidence is low
Firstly, consumer confidence is being regularly hit by worldwide economic factors such as inflation and rising interest rates that create spending uncertainty. Evidence from the British Retail Consortium (BRC), suggests shop prices rose in February at their fastest rate in more than a decade as the cost of living crisis intensifies. Retail price annual inflation accelerated to 1.8 per cent in February, the highest rate of inflation since November 2011. Inflation in food prices is the main contributor, but the increase was also driven by non-food items such as cosmetics and furniture.
Rapid price rises have left customers pessimistic about their finances with consumer confidence falling to its lowest level since January last year, when England entered its third lockdown. It’s now more important than ever for retailers to create genuine connections with their customers to build better engagement and increase their lifetime value (LTV).
For many ecommerce brands, the natural response is to continually run promotions and sales, keeping customers coming through the door and avoiding an overload of stock, but leaving the traditional sales calendar null and void.
Consumers are being more selective
Secondly, consumers are becoming more selective about the brands they shop with. No longer making decisions based purely on price and promotions, shoppers are prioritising purchases with brands that are aligned with their values. Our research suggests that just over half (56%) of consumers feel brands care more about selling products over supporting causes or living their values, disappointing given the rise in conscious consumerism.
However, brands like Patagonia, which has marketed itself as a for-the-environment retailer since its conception, have recently spoken out about businesses greenwashing and companies inflating their sustainability to lure in consumers. Retailers would do well to note that without evidence to substantiate claims, focusing on conscious consumerism can have the opposite impact on shoppers. In 2011 Patagonia issued a full-page advert in the New York Times urging customers to rethink their Black Friday purchases, even at the risk of missing out on extra cash.
Skip forward to 2022 and the pandemic has almost certainly influenced how and where consumers prioritise spending their money. Many see membership to a private community of like-minded shoppers or the opportunity to contribute to a charity that’s aligned with their values key attributes in influencing where they shop (54% and 62%). The lure of low prices is no longer a sufficient way of driving sales. Customers are basing their decisions on much more than that.
Shoppers are demanding more
And finally, today’s shoppers want a lot more in return for their purchase than just a discounted product. They want a high standard of customer service, to feel as though their custom is valued, and to connect with a brand on a deeper level.
Over two-thirds (68%) of customers say they would be loyal to a brand if it shared the same values as them. Whilst, 66% of customers said they would join a loyalty program if they could create ongoing relationships with the brands they like. Additionally, 55% of customers say their loyalty would be won if they had an emotional connection to it.
Discounts no longer meet the priorities of customers and won’t help retailers to build lifetime value and brand loyalty. Instead, they have to offer alternatives that make shoppers feel positive about their brand at the point of purchase and motivate them to return all year long.
In conclusion
Relying on discounts isn’t sustainable if a brand needs to run them all year round. At a time when consumers are savvier with their spending, discounts still have a part to play in retailers’ day-to-day operations. But they don’t always bring in the right kind of customers that turn into life-long brand insiders.
Brands with modest and infrequent discounts are healthier than those caught up in a sale-driven approach that erodes CLTV with each year a customer shops at a discounted rate. Plus, reversing out of a discount-heavy strategy can result in a sales decline while customers who are used to lower prices reassess their options.
Substituting promotions for the alternatives that promote positive sentiments to a brand and drive sales, such as loyalty points and rewards or free shipping, will reduce a brand’s reliance on discounting and build stronger, long-term customer relationships that keep profits high all year round.
