Industry News • Premier Retail

Social commerce: How should brands navigate this new frontier?

Social commerce: How should brands navigate this new frontier?
Written by Amy

by Nina Müller, Director of The Ethical Commerce Alliance

Whether it’s completely new social media platforms or new functionalities on existing apps, we’ve seen how consumers flocking to these  features and platforms can create a huge amount of hype and excitement. For brands and businesses the sense of ‘FOMO’ can be hard to resist, and the urge to reach new audiences is all consuming.

This phenomenon has already started to take place in retail with social commerce. TikTok’s live stream shopping and Instagram shopping have taken a retail brand’s presence on these platforms to a new stage. It’s no longer just a way to communicate with customers but is a platform where purchases and sales can be generated. With eCommerce businesses generating over £500bn worth of sales worldwide through social commerce in 2022, there’s a clear opportunity for retailers to expand into a new channel of commerce, but what’s the catch?

Digital Trust and ethical commerce

Digital trust is on the minds of many social media users, with the majority of Brits saying social media is where they felt their data was most at risk. Social media platforms have frequently made headlines for all the wrong reasons, from being sued by regulatory bodies, for illegally violating users’ privacy. the collection of biometric data to the unconsented tracking of users’ location. Consequently there is a clear question mark around the ethical validity around social media which can potentially have a detrimental impact on a retailer’s brand.

Social platforms have been built on implicit trust from consumers and now that scrutiny circles these Big Tech companies, retailers will have to navigate many challenges to operate effectively and ethically in this space.

 Outside of significant data privacy scandals, social media platforms have also spurred the rise of misinformation, harmful content and ‘cancel culture’. Protective measures such as content moderation now exist to limit this but it doesn’t address the problematic dynamics of social media such as addiction, manipulation and impacted mental health.

When nearly half of children and teenagers aged between 8-17 use TikTok and Instagram, the ethical implications of social media platforms laxed ethical behaviour is dangerous. This becomes even more problematic with the current shift away from ‘friends and family’ content to unconnected algorithm driven material, that platforms like TikTok use.

From a birds eye view, it’s clear this business model doesn’t advocate responsibility, transparency or respect – the exact building blocks needed for ethical commerce.

Navigating the tricky landscape of social commerce

Approaching social commerce without considerations around the impact on consumer trust, can make selling on these platforms a slippery slope. The opaque privacy policies and ambiguous data practices of Big Tech means new channels such as TikTok Shop are nothing short of a black box.

The crux of the issue is control. Retailer’s operating on social platforms to engage with Gen Z consumers, need to consider that TikTok and Instagram are expanding beyond commerce services and  becoming the digital infrastructure of engagement. What is then lost are important touch points that many retailers rely on.

By engaging with TikTok Shop or Instagram shopping, retailers can actually increase the distance between users and the business. Whilst product discovery becomes more authentic and selling becomes frictionless, the more narrow parts of the funnel are streamlined, creating the potential for an experience which may not align with retailer’s brands.

Another element lost in the social media black box is ethical practices. Through owned e-commerce channels, retailer’s can dictate which cookies are used, how much data is collected and what happens to such information post-purchase. But with social commerce platforms, retailers become subject to the same ethical standards Meta, TikTok and SnapChat all live up to, which we know isn’t a high bar.

When less than one-fifth of consumers trust the UK’s leading retailers, the decision to join the social commerce bandwagon seems ever so risky.

Elevated brand behaviour 

To ensure retailers engage with consumers on social media in a safe and protected way, consumers need to see elevated standards around transparency, inclusion and respect.

Whilst social commerce is seen as a jackpot to many retailers, the ambiguity of the commerce channel and scrutiny of social media platforms’ reputations fails to offer retailers the above principles. That said, there are a number of ways social media can be used that allow retailers to increase purchasing decisions but maintain control over important touch points.

The key to doing so is through a caution-first approach. With the pitfalls and concerns surrounding social media, retailers must consider and respect consumers’ digital rights above their own needs. This is especially felt when it comes to data transparency, ownership and inclusion around new commerce channels. That’s not to say retailers need to boycott social media but rather consider the perils of personalisation and concerns around children’s online safety when using platforms that aren’t adequately regulated.

Retail brands that decide to jump in with both feet into the quickly developing social commerce space are playing a risky game. There are still several unknowns around how these new features operate and the ethical standards of many social media platforms. The potential negative impact on brand reputation especially as consumers become increasingly conscious of their own online privacy and the negative impacts of social media is significant. Retailers need to ensure they are in control of how they engage with their audiences on these platforms and instil their own standards. Only then can they avoid the potential pitfalls that come with social commerce

About the author

Amy