Written By Ian Gulliford, Environmental Services Director, William Martin
The news that over 100 English schools, that have been partially constructed with reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC), will have to close until they can be made safe will have come as a massive shock to families still recovering from the impact of Covid closures.
But with the Health and Safety Executive stating that RAAC is now beyond its lifespan and may “collapse with little or no notice”, and the news that a beam failed in a primary school over the summer holidays, it’s clear that there was little choice if pupils and teachers are to be kept safe.
And while RAAC is something most parents had never previously heard of, one word everyone is familiar with – for all the wrong reasons – is asbestos. And it’s that much-feared substance that could end up causing even greater problems for the RAAC-affected schools.
Despite being completely banned in 1999, asbestos remains in 80% of our school buildings and is still Britain’s number one work-related killer. In 2019 alone, there were more than 5,000 deaths with links to asbestos.
Over the summer, health experts began to warn that crumbling concrete in schools, hospitals and other public buildings would increase the danger of asbestos exposure. Because it was commonly used to construct buildings from the 1950s to 1990s, RAAC is often present in the very same buildings as asbestos – often hidden away in the structure of the building, such as roof voids.
And while that asbestos may not be harmful if left undisturbed, it might be a completely different matter if a roof collapses or needs to be removed. This could potentially release fibres that, if inhaled, can cause serious health issues like mesothelioma.
Like all public buildings, every school should have carried out a recent asbestos management survey to identify whether the offending material is present in their building. If it is, they’re obliged to keep an asbestos register pinpointing where it’s located. A decision would have then been made, based on location and condition of the asbestos, whether it needed to be immediately removed or whether the risk could be managed by keeping a close eye on it.
If in any doubt at all about whether asbestos is present, samples need to be taken. A head teacher may find, for example, that a classroom ceiling is asbestos. Even taking samples from concrete panels can potentially disturb asbestos fibres.
In an ideal world, any remediation work that will need to take place in RAAC-affected schools would happen as quickly as possible to minimise disruption to education. However, any such works on schools with asbestos present will need an asbestos refurbishment survey to be completed before they can start. There have been several prosecutions of organisations undertaking works on properties without a refurbishment survey in place, where potential exposures have occurred.
And of course, anyone carrying out such a survey, or any refurbishment work that might disturb asbestos, needs to be appropriately trained. Bringing in a specialist company to do this is going to add time and cost to the job – at a time when nobody can really afford either.
Latest reports from the HSE showed that 7% of their school inspections identified unacceptable standards of asbestos management that required enforcement action, showing that possession of an asbestos survey report does not necessarily confirm the risk is being adequately managed.
It is essential therefore to review the available asbestos information prior to embarking on any investigative work for RAAC and where there is any doubt whatsoever then further surveying, inspection or sampling for asbestos should be carried out. Of course, there is an urgent need to speed up the identification and assessment of any RAAC in a school building but the safety of those conducting those inspections and those assisting must not be sacrificed in pursuit of quick answers in the glare of public opinion.
I believe we should now be moving the debate firmly away from managing asbestos in school buildings to a proactive management approach of systematic removal – and this latest issue clearly demonstrates why.
We have hundreds of legacy system-built schools throughout the UK that are beyond their expected build life. Waiting for the next issue to occur only puts the health and safety of pupils and staff at unnecessary and avoidable risk. Can we afford to keep taking that chance?
