Industry News • Premier Construction

Managing the people side of construction: how to improve safety, motivation and attract new talent

Written by SL@Roma
By Dominic Ashley-Timms, Founder and CEO of Notion

Whilst the construction industry is known for its fast-paced, high-stress environment, it’s also the UK’s most dangerous, reporting twice as many work-related deaths than forestry, fishing, agriculture and manufacturing combined.

When we’re managing the people within this setting, we want them to be efficient whilst staying safe and feel motivated by the work that they do. But the outdated model of management that prevails across the sector is one of authority, servitude and fear, where employees simply carry out orders. It’s no wonder the industry is experiencing an unprecedented labour shortage, needing nearly a million new recruits over the next decade.

So, what can those managing construction sites do to foster an improved culture of safety whilst increasing efficiency, maintaining motivation and attracting new talent?

Command-and-control is outmoded

Management practice has progressed little within the construction sector. Hierarchy remains an underpinning factor in day-to-day relationships, where managers often feel pressure to direct employees, emulating the type of managers they’ve experienced in the past.

This command-and-control approach isn’t unique to the building trade – it’s rife in business, public services, health settings and more. But in the high-pressure construction environment, where safety is paramount and mistakes are not easily rectified, things can get tense – and quickly.

Enjoying this article? Sign up for our FREE newsletter!

When employees ask a manager for help or report a problem, a common reaction is to try and solve this immediately, jumping in with solutions and directing a response. This does little to develop others; if you do the thinking for someone, they’ll continue to come to you with issues instead of options or solutions. Similarly, when something goes wrong on site, particularly when safety has been compromised, it can be easy to react with an inflammatory response.

Naturally, as a manager, you want to impress upon your people the danger associated with what has just happened and the gravity of the situation. But often, this is the wrong time to dole out chastisements – instead, the key to improving safety on a site is encouraging people to develop their own mental model of personal safety, which would prevent them from behaving the same way again. To do this, managers must employ an enquiry-led approach—learning to ask more powerful, insightful questions. Not necessarily in the heat of the moment but finding the time afterwards to have that enquiry-led conversation.

Adopting an enquiry-led approach

When a manager asks a question of an employee, that employee is forced to use their own problem-solving skills to solve an issue or to reflect on an incident. For example, “What could have been the impact of that?” or “Is there a way we could achieve a different result?”. Questions like these help employees to construct new insights and make new linkages between their behaviour and the outcome, which influences their reaction the next time they experience that situation.

We call this a ‘mental model’ because the aim is to instil a change in someone’s behaviour that is unconscious and long-term. If a manager consistently tells others how to behave, they don’t take accountability and there’s been no reasoned development in their own decision-making abilities – they will continue to require direction.

Picking the right moment within a busy construction environment isn’t always easy. Still, it’s important to remember that coaching conversations such as these are a much more respectful way of engaging with employees—fear-based behaviour developed as a response to being ‘told off’ simply isn’t sustainable. Instead, managers learning to ask powerful questions that get others to think for themselves promotes psychological safety and shows concern for their welfare and development.

Another aspect of developing new mental models with the safety agenda in mind is appreciative feedback. This means drawing attention to the positive behaviours that you want to see from employees, such as praising someone when they undertake a preventative action without direction, “Thanks so much for spotting that XYZ needed cleaning up”. If you’re only waiting for someone to do something wrong to outline unwanted behaviour, it’s too late.

Operational Coaching®

Using a sustained, enquiry-led approach in this way (something known as an Operational Coaching® style of management) was proven to be effective in UK Government-backed research conducted by the London School of Economics (LSE). They found that across sixty-two organisations, managers who undertook a new programme called STAR® Manager learned to develop their awareness and adopt new behaviours that led to a six-fold improvement in employee retention and 48% of reported successes related to increased engagement and productivity. Jewson and National Express both recorded improvements in yard safety and driver behaviour respectively, as a result of having had managers learn these new skills.

Despite the estimated cost of injury and ill health to the construction sector exceeding £1.2 billion, the probable impact of poorly trained managers is rarely discussed. Managers lay the foundations on which culture, safety and productivity are built. Construction industry leaders need urgently to invest in upskilling their ability to extract the maximum amount of talent from their teams by teaching them how to engage the thinking of others whilst maintaining a safe and respectful environment.

And who wouldn’t want to work in an environment like that?

Dominic Ashley-Timms is the CEO of performance consultancy Notion, creators of the multi-award-winning and globally-certified STAR® Manager programme being adopted by managers and leaders in over 40 countries. Dominic is also the co-author of new management bestseller The Answer is a Question.

Want to get more great stories from across the construction industry sent straight to your inbox? Click here to sign up for our weekly newsletter!

About the author

SL@Roma