By Fayola-Maria Jack, CEO and founder of Resolutiion
As we head further into 2025, British retailers continue to face a lethal combination of challenges. Global, local, internal and external, these challenges – ranging from cost pressures and ESG demands to fierce competition and labour shortages – are all triggering a rise in supply chain disputes.
A ‘dispute’, which does not just mean litigation, but rather a conflict that’s not been resolved through negotiation between stakeholders within 2-3 weeks, leads to disruption. In turn, disruptions can not only damage important supplier relationships, brand reputation and customer satisfaction, but can lead to material financial repercussions. In fact, research indicates that the increased operational costs caused by disruptions average 6-10% of annual revenues. While this is a huge amount of money for most retailers, often these financial ramifications are not understood or even tracked.
With this in mind, it’s not only key to understand the root cause of these disputes, but also know how to implement practical strategies to prevent conflict in the first place, helping retailers maintain strong supplier partnerships, keep shelves stocked, customers happy and protect their bottom line.
Key challenges leading to supplier-retailer disputes
- Tariffs and inflation: Of all the challenges, tariffs and inflation – key material trade barriers – have to be up there as the most material trigger for retailer-supplier disputes. Particularly in 2025. Both see costs rise for suppliers, which they then attempt to pass onto retailers, who, in an attempt to balance profits, pass onto consumers. All of this creates tension and introduces uncertainties right across the supply chain, often triggering retailers to rapidly reassess strategy and expenditure. And this isn’t just something we’re seeing in the UK. Just this February, the US services sector contracted for the first time since January 2023, reflecting how mounting tariff-induced supplier price hikes and geopolitical shifts are eroding consumer confidence.
- Labour shortages: Disrupting the balance of agreed pricing and delivery schedules, labour shortages can create significant friction in supplier-retailer relationships. For example, suppliers facing rising raw material costs and limited manpower may seek to increase prices and delay shipments to cope with operational pressures. Retailers, often locked into fixed-price contracts and bound by strict seasonal deadlines, push back, arguing that any deviation undermines their operational commitments. This tension can escalate quickly, with suppliers signaling a willingness to prioritise more flexible customers and retailers resorting to legal actions to uphold contract terms, ultimately straining the trust and stability essential for long-term partnerships.
- ESG demands vs cost pressures: Alongside the pressure to control costs amidst tariffs, inflation and labour challenges, retailers are also pushing for higher levels of transparency, ethics and sustainability. This means they’re increasingly scrutinising their supplier bases, favouring those that can deliver on robust ESG credentials. This shift forces suppliers to invest in sustainable practices and enhance their transparency, which can lead to higher operational costs. Many suppliers, especially long-established ones, may find it difficult to meet these evolving standards without compromising their competitive pricing, creating a natural tension. At the same time, rather than broadening their supplier network, many retailers are opting for a more selective approach. It’s a strategy that’s leading to intensifying competition among suppliers to prove their value on both cost and ethical fronts. All of this can lead to strained relationships and disagreements over pricing, the pace of necessary reforms, and of course quality.
- Quality and compliance issues: When goods don’t meet the agreed and expected standards, in terms of either quality or compliance, conflict is almost inevitable. Right now, retailers in the clothing space are battling high returns that have increased year on year. These items flow back into the supply chain, and whilst some retailers in the clothing space are now charging customers for online returns in an attempt to reduce them, it’s still problematic financially, and has increased the back and forth with suppliers over quality. Retailers will commonly demand retrospective discounts as financial compensation, and this often extends to things like late delivery. Any demand for financial compensation of this nature will impact supplier revenue and often creates long-term friction in the relationship.
- Poor management of contractual details: Gaps and ambiguities in contracts are as common as they are unhelpful. When agreements are signed and filed away and core terms are adhered to, but the granular details in the contract are missed – which happens more often than many imagine – this is a major trigger for disputes. When there’s friction, it’s common to see parties pull out the contract and focus on the overlooked details for leverage.
- Technological advancements: The retail industry is undergoing a major transformation driven by e-commerce, with technology playing a critical role in optimising operations and enhancing customer experiences. But these pros come with cons. Mainly, major advancements in tech have increased the number of market players tremendously, as we see a growing number of new retailers taking advantage of the e-commerce space, which has a low barrier to entry. This is increasing strong competition on a global scale, while customer expectations have evolved massively. Operating amidst this fierce competition – affecting both retailers and suppliers alike – creates material tension.
Enjoying this article? Sign up for our FREE newsletter!
Practical strategies for avoiding disputes
- Clear contractual agreements: It’s really important for suppliers to be on top of obligations, but it’s also important to ensure that contracts are understandable, and well drafted. As such, contracts should really focus on the scope of work, pricing, delivery schedules, and quality standards to preempt misunderstandings. They should also contain a mechanism for swift conflict and dispute resolution, that favours negotiation and facilitation by a third party, over costly legal processes. Finally, contractual delivery needs to be much better managed, so that issues on the horizon become much more visible and trends are quickly spotted.
- Embrace AI: When it comes to contractual delivery needs, retailers and suppliers alike should look to agentic AI to manage specific challenges, versus traditional contract administration software platforms that have fallen short over the years. And this advice doesn’t just start and stop with contracts. With the introduction of AI, there is lots of new technology available for retailers, and procurement teams are now turning their attention to getting the technology right. It’s my view that the first to embrace AI technologies will ultimately rocket productivity and outcomes, and will win in terms of customer sentiment and profitability, seeing an almost immediate ROI.
- Regular performance reviews: Early identification of potential issues based on target outcomes allows for timely intervention, ensuring that suppliers remain reliable partners and the relationship remains aligned. As such, I advocate the use of OKRs over SLAs as the framework to measure performance. This is because an outcome-based approach is much more effective than focusing on minimum standards for assessing operational performance. Many relationships have material issues even though minimum standards set by SLAs are being met.
- Collaborative activities: Whether it’s goal-setting sessions or joint business planning sessions to align on forecasts, demand planning, and market strategy, collaboration ensures that both retailer and suppliers are on the same page, reducing the likelihood of disputes arising from misaligned objectives and expectations. Again this can all be done with technology to reduce the burden on time and resources.
- Third party conflict resolution: In cases where conflict can’t be avoided, it must instead be resolved. Here, a third party can help to establish the core issues and engage the parties in open discussions to build trust. So, instead of resorting to a legal battle, terminating, or damaging a critical relationship, a balanced resolution that protects mutual interests can be met, whether it’s an agreed tiered price adjustment, a mechanism for automatic reviews based on market condition triggers, partial advance payments for high-priority orders or the introduction of a cost-sharing mechanism reducing the risk of similar disputes.
Why strong relationships matter
In a market increasingly contested by agile online competitors, where aggressive cost reduction is a constant priority, the ability to avoid costly conflicts and disruptions, and even secure better pricing and payment terms through trusted partnerships, has never been more important.
A harmonious supplier relationship also minimises disruptions and enables retailers to meet customer demands more effectively. Finally, brand reputation is everything in retail. Retailers need to do all they can to bolster market reputation, increase customer loyalty, and increase competitive advantage; which is why, as well as considering how disputes are handled in the supply chain, retailers must also think about how disputes are managed with consumers.
The bottom line is, strong relationships are not just a nicety, they equal stability, resilience, operational efficiency and often reduced costs; all vitally important for the industry’s economic success and future stability.
