Colin Light, Global Sector Lead – Rail Buildings, Ramboll
Much has been made recently of the important role that transport plays in connecting communities and enabling economic growth. That is all quite true, with numerous studies showing that investments in transport infrastructure can have a multiplying effect on economic growth in a local area. However, the issue of accessibility is too often left out of these conversations.
This is surprising for two reasons. Firstly, accessibility is a legal requirement under the Equality Act 2010 and related accessibility obligations across the transport sector. Secondly, inaccessibility is a barrier to economic growth, with a recent report by the Institution of Mechanical Engineers finding that making the UK transport network fully accessible could boost the economy by £176bn.
It’s vital that we recognise this now, given that we are entering a significant phase of rail infrastructure development, including the HS2 reset, Northern Powerhouse Rail and East West Rail. Embedding accessibility as a core objective in the planning phase of all projects is critical. We also need to recognise that the scale of the challenge is significant, not least because so much of the rail network in the UK was set out in the Victorian era when accessibility was not a consideration.
Progress is being made on improving accessibility – Network Rail’s Access for All Programme has resulted in a number of successes, both standalone projects and through integrating accessibility requirements into broader schemes. But there is still more that needs to be done; recent Government research indicates that less than a third of all railway stations in the UK are fully step free.
Integrating accessibility
Station upgrades provide an important opportunity to improve accessibility at scale across the rail network. Enhancements might be simple, for example providing tactile paving, ramps, wide pathways, improved lighting, audio-visual announcements, and improvements to signage. These can make an immediate positive difference, though it may also be necessary to make more significant, complex interventions, such as building new footbridges or installing lifts.
These wayfinding improvements can all improve passenger experience by reducing friction between the street and the platform. This will benefit all passengers but it can be particularly important for those who do require more accessible routes – making journeys easier and faster, which increases the likelihood that they can make use of public transport.
Enjoying this article? Sign up for our FREE newsletter!
Upgrade works can be costly and time consuming, particularly where stations must remain operational and construction has to be carried out overnight, but there are ways to minimise disruption. One of the most effective is the use of Modern Methods of Construction (MMC). Although not a cure-all, MMC allows components and systems to be manufactured offsite and brought to stations for final assembly, reducing time on site and minimising disruption to day-to-day operations. It can also reduce waste and embodied carbon, while enabling proven designs to be replicated more efficiently across the network, all helping to speed up the rollout of proven accessible solutions.
Achieving standardisation
The advantages of productised design highlights one of the other key accessibility barriers that needs to be overcome, namely that there is very little standardisation across the rail network. This is understandable given that we have a history of rail dating back two centuries in the UK, but that does not make tackling it any less important.
The boarding (and disembarking) process provides an instructive example. Although taken for granted by many, it is an essential part of any journey but can be particularly challenging for those with accessibility requirements. There are significant differences in platform heights and train floor heights. Many platforms are also curved, which creates variable stepping distances – not necessarily an obvious accessibility issue but a very real concern for many passengers.
The current solution to enable boarding is generally reliant on ramps. This is certainly better than nothing but is a long way short of being an ideal solution – not least because ramps need to be arranged in advance and require station staff to be present to help. This can be a source of real anxiety for passengers, particularly those who have experienced the promised help at a station failing to materialise. The long term solution is greater standardisation of platform and train interface design, including alignment of platform and train door threshold levels.
The benefits of standardisation can also be applied more widely across operation and maintenance. For example, standardising the type and configuration of lifts can make a large impact on the passenger experience, as well as making it that much easier for faults to be repaired by removing the requirement for bespoke parts to be acquired.
Delivering change
There are numerous rail projects on the horizon (or already underway) to ensure that the UK’s rail network is ready for the future. This creates an opportunity to embed accessibility more deeply across the network — one we cannot afford to miss. The rewards of a truly inclusive rail network that can be used by all passengers are significant. So now is the time to make accessibility our priority.
